How ERP AI Chatbots Are Reshaping Enterprise Workflows in US

Date :
May 1, 2026
Listed by :
Neha
Sidebar
How ERP AI Chatbots Are Reshaping Enterprise Workflows in US

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • ERP AI chatbots replace rigid menu navigation with plain-language queries. Your teams get answers, approvals, and reports in seconds instead of waiting on support tickets.
  • These are not generic chatbots retrofitted to your ERP. They are AI systems built into your ERP’s data and workflow layer. That distinction defines their value entirely.
  • US enterprises integrating AI into ERP workflows report a 20 to 40 percent reduction in manual processing effort, with the highest gains across finance, HR, and supply chain.
  • The strongest ROI comes from internal, employee-facing deployments. Ticket deflection, decision speed, and ERP adoption rates are the metrics that actually move the business case.
  • Architecture determines everything. A chatbot that reads ERP data but cannot trigger workflows is a sophisticated FAQ tool, not an automation layer worth the investment.
  • Security and compliance are non-negotiable. Your ERP holds your most sensitive business data. SOC 2, CCPA, and HIPAA frameworks must be built in from day one, not added after launch.
  • Custom development by an ERP-experienced team consistently outperforms off-the-shelf tools. The difference shows up in adoption rates and in workflows that hold up under actual daily use.

 

The average US enterprise spends between $150,000 and $750,000 implementing an ERP system. Most employees interact with it fewer than three times a day, through interfaces designed for IT specialists, not operations professionals.

The ERP is not the bottleneck. The interface is.

Every budget query routed through a support ticket, every inventory check that takes three menu layers, every approval chain that stalls over a weekend. These are interface failures, not ERP failures.

An AI chatbot layer solves them directly. It turns the ERP your teams already have into a system they will actually use.

This blog breaks down exactly how ERP AI chatbots work, the types available to US enterprises today, where they generate the highest return, and what it takes to build one that performs at production scale.

Whether you are evaluating this for the first time or ready to scope a build, every section here gives you a practical framework. No filler. Just what decision-makers need to move forward with the right development partner.

What Is an ERP AI Chatbot?

An ERP AI chatbot is a conversational AI system integrated directly into an enterprise resource planning platform. It allows users to query live data, trigger workflows, and complete multi-step processes in plain language, without navigating the ERP interface manually.

It does not answer from a static knowledge base but connects to your live ERP data, understands business context, and acts on it in real time.

Three components make this work. The NLP and language model layer understands what the user is asking. The integration layer connects to the ERP through APIs or native connectors. The ERP data and logic layer is where the actual action happens.

All three must work together. Weak integration produces a chatbot that sounds capable and delivers nothing. That is where most off-the-shelf tools fall short.

The distinction US enterprises should internalize before scoping any build: a chatbot layered loosely on top of your ERP is not the same as one architecturally embedded within it. The former reads data. The latter reads, reasons, and acts on it.

Once the definition is clear, the next question is which type of ERP AI chatbot matches your organization’s needs and scale.

Types of ERP AI Chatbots: Choosing the Right Fit

Not all ERP AI chatbots are built the same. The type you choose determines how much of your ERP the chatbot can reach, how well it handles real employee queries, and how far it can scale without a rebuild.

US enterprises evaluating this technology should understand the five primary types before scoping any build. Moving forward with the wrong type is one of the most common reasons deployments underdeliver.

Types of ERP AI Chatbots 

Type How It Works Best For Limitations
Rule-Based  Follows predefined scripts and decision trees  Simple, repetitive, predictable queries  Breaks outside its script; cannot handle variations or follow-ups 
NLP-Powered AI  Understands natural language intent and query variations  Most enterprise use cases: queries, reports, status checks  Needs domain-specific ERP training to perform accurately 
Generative AI (LLM)  Uses large language models to generate contextual responses, summaries, and recommendations  Complex queries, report generation, multi-turn conversation  Requires governance controls and hallucination safeguards 
Voice-Enabled  Processes spoken queries via speech-to-text and NLP  Warehouse, field operations, hands-free environments  Sensitive to ambient noise; deeper integration complexity 
Agentic Chatbots Autonomously executes multi-step workflows without prompting at each step  Advanced automation: procurement cycles, approvals, escalations  Highest complexity; requires robust guardrails and audit trails 

 

Most US enterprise deployments in 2025 and 2026 are landing on NLP-powered or generative AI chatbots as the production-grade standard. They are powerful enough to handle real workflow complexity and mature enough to govern responsibly.

Understanding the type is step one. Understanding why the traditional ERP interface created the need for them in the first place is step two

Watch Our Video: How to Build & Sell AI Agents in 2026

 

 

Why US Enterprises Can No Longer Ignore This Shift

The ERP adoption paradox is well-documented across US organizations. Companies invest heavily in SAP, Oracle, Microsoft Dynamics, and custom-built systems. Then most employees access a fraction of what those systems can actually do.

The interfaces were not designed for the people who need them most.

The hidden cost lives in friction. A finance analyst submits a ticket to pull a variance report. A procurement manager manually checks PO status twice a day. A warehouse supervisor is calling IT for inventory data because the ERP interface takes too long.

These are measurable hours. Multiplied across departments and quarters, ERP interface friction is one of the most underreported operational costs in US enterprise environments.

North America holds 38.4% of the global AI-in-ERP market. McKinsey research estimates AI integration across enterprise workflows could unlock up to $4.4 trillion in global productivity gains. US enterprises moving first on this are not just improving efficiency. They are building a competitive gap that compounds.

Three-stat visual showing the gap between ERP investment, daily active usage, and AI-driven efficiency potential

The technology that closes that gap has a specific architecture. That architecture determines whether your chatbot delivers the return or simply creates a new IT maintenance obligation. 

Not sure how AI Chatbot can fix your ERP environment?

 

How ERP AI Chatbots Work — And Why Architecture Determines Everything

The Core Processing Flow

Five steps happen every time a user sends a query. They submit the question in plain language. The NLP and language model layer identifies their intent and extracts key entities. 

An API call routes to the relevant ERP module. The ERP processes the request and returns data or executes the action. The chatbot delivers a formatted, contextual response.

When properly built, this entire loop runs in seconds.

The critical variable is step three. A chatbot built on a shallow API connection can retrieve surface-level data. 

A chatbot with deep ERP integration — one built by engineers who understand how SAP modules interact, how Oracle’s data layer is structured, how Dynamics 365 connects back-office functions — can trigger workflows, execute approvals, and act on business logic.

That depth is what separates automation from information retrieval. It is also what most off-the-shelf chatbot tools are not equipped to provide.

Integration Approaches by ERP Platform

The right integration method depends on your ERP platform, the depth of automation you need, and your existing IT infrastructure. Here is where the choices sit across the major platforms used by US enterprises.

Integration Approaches by ERP Platform 

ERP Platform Integration Method Capabilities Complexity
SAP S/4HANA  SAP Conversational AI + REST APIs / Business Technology Platform  Finance, procurement, supply chain, HR queries plus workflow triggers  Medium to High 
Oracle ERP Cloud  REST/SOAP APIs + Oracle Digital Assistant  All modules; multi-step workflow execution  High 
Microsoft Dynamics 365  Power Platform + Azure Bot Service + Copilot Studio  CRM-ERP queries, approval workflows, Teams integration  Medium
NetSuite  SuiteScript + REST APIs  Finance, inventory, order management queries  Medium
Custom or Legacy ERP  Custom API layer plus middleware  Dependent on existing architecture and data accessibility  High
Multi-ERP environments  Unified API gateway / Enterprise Service Bus  Cross-system queries and unified employee interface  Very High 

Core Features to Require from Any ERP AI Chatbot Build

Before you approve a development scope, these eight capabilities belong in the architecture as baseline requirements. If a vendor treats any of them as optional add-ons, that is a signal about how the build will perform.

Core Features of a Production-Ready ERP AI Chatbot 

Feature What It Does Why It Matters
Natural Language Understanding (NLU)  Identifies user intent even in informal, unstructured queries  Real employees do not query in structured language 
Real-Time ERP Data Access  Pulls live data, not cached or static snapshots  Decisions based on stale data cost more than no chatbot at all 
Multi-Module Workflow Triggering  Executes actions across finance, HR, and supply chain modules  This separates automation from information retrieval 
Role-Based Access Control (RBAC)  Limits data access by user role and permissions  Critical for SOC 2, HIPAA, and CCPA compliance 
Omnichannel Deployment  Runs on MS Teams, Slack, web widget, and mobile  Employees use it where they already work 
Contextual Multi-Turn Memory  Maintains conversation context across follow-up questions  Users should not have to repeat context with every query 
Audit Trail and Compliance Logging  Records all interactions for compliance review  Non-negotiable for regulated US industries 
Continuous Learning Loop  Improves from real user interactions over time  Prevents adoption drop-off that kills post-launch ROI 

 

How an ERP AI Chatbot Works infographic showing a 5-step flow from User Query through NLP Layer, API Connector, ERP Data Layer, to Formatted Response

With architecture and features established, the practical question for US decision-makers becomes: where inside the organization does this investment return the most, and the fastest? 

Where ERP AI Chatbots Deliver Maximum Impact Across US Enterprise Functions

The highest-return ERP AI chatbot deployments target the workflows where employees spend the most time navigating the system instead of doing actual work. These five areas are where US enterprises consistently find that intersection.

Finance and Reporting

Budget variance queries, cash flow snapshots, invoice status checks, and period-close reporting no longer require an analyst to run them manually. Finance teams get live ERP data delivered in the same conversation, formatted and ready.

For US organizations operating under GAAP reporting pressure, the combination of speed and accuracy is not a convenience. It is an operational requirement.

HR and Employee Self-Service

Leave balances, payroll inquiries, benefits questions, and onboarding task tracking are all handled through a single conversational interface. HR tickets that used to occupy a specialist’s afternoon get resolved in under a minute.

For mid-size US enterprises running lean HR teams, this one use case alone frequently covers the total cost of the build.

Supply Chain and Inventory Management

Real-time stock levels, reorder alerts, shipment tracking, and supplier performance data are available through a single query. The chatbot can also trigger purchase orders within pre-approved thresholds without requiring a manual workflow.

For US manufacturers and distributors, this compresses decision cycles on which supply chain responsiveness depends. Delays measured in hours become responses measured in seconds.

Procurement and Vendor Management

PO status, vendor scorecards, contract expiry alerts, and sourcing recommendations all surface through the same interface employees already use. 

AI-driven procurement chatbots have also shown measurable reductions in processing errors for organizations running high-volume purchasing operations.

Customer Operations and Order Management

Internal teams handling escalations pull order histories, credit limits, and fulfillment statuses in seconds. Resolution times drop without requiring agents to switch systems, call IT, or wait on a colleague to run a report.

ERP AI Chatbot Impact by Department infographic showing benefits across Finance, HR, Supply Chain, Procurement, and Customer Ops

 

Key Benefits of ERP AI Chatbots for US Enterprises

ROI tables tell part of the story. The business case for ERP AI chatbots in US environments runs deeper than time savings and ticket deflection. These are the strategic advantages decision-makers consistently report after deployment.

Higher ERP Adoption Across the Organization

When employees can interact with a $500,000 ERP system through a natural conversation instead of a training manual, they use it. ERP adoption rates are the single most undervalued metric in platform investment performance. 

A chatbot that raises daily active usage from 20% to 60% of your workforce changes the return on an investment you have already made.

Faster, Data-Driven Decisions at Every Level

When a plant manager, a finance director, and an HR lead can all query the same system in plain language, decision-making spreads beyond the specialist tier. 

Insights that previously required a trained analyst become available at the exact moment they are needed.

Scalability Without Proportional Headcount Growth

A well-built ERP chatbot handles thousands of queries simultaneously. For US growth-stage enterprises managing cost structure, scaling operations no longer requires scaling support headcount at the same rate. 

That ratio shift is a direct contribution to operating margin.

Reduced Operational Errors

Manual data entry and manual report generation are two of the highest error-risk activities in ERP environments. Automating both cuts error rates and the downstream rework they create. 

Heineken’s procurement chatbot deployment brought error rates from 30% down to 5%. That level of accuracy improvement has hard cost implications.

Competitive Positioning in an AI-Mature Market

US enterprises that move on ERP AI adoption now are building an operational infrastructure gap that competitors will struggle to close quickly. This is not a future investment. 

It is a present competitive decision. The organizations treating it that way in 2026 will hold the advantage through the end of the decade.

These benefits become measurable when you know which metrics to track. That is where the ROI framework comes in.

 

ERP AI Chatbot ROI: Business Outcomes You Can Measure

Every benefit in the previous section has a corresponding metric. US enterprises building the internal business case for an ERP AI chatbot should track these by function, before and after deployment.

Enterprises integrating AI into ERP workflows report a 20 to 40 percent reduction in manual processing effort. AI-powered self-service typically deflects 25 to 40 percent of internal HR and IT support ticket volume. Decision cycles that previously required multi-step ERP navigation compress from hours to seconds.

ROI Metrics by Enterprise Function 

Function Metric to Track Benchmark Range
Finance  Time to generate budget or variance reports  70–85% time reduction 
HR  Internal ticket deflection rate  25–40% of HR ticket volume 
Supply Chain  Inventory query resolution time  60–80% faster 
Procurement  PO status turnaround  Same-session resolution 
IT / ERP Support  ERP helpdesk ticket volume  20–35% reduction 
Operations  Routine approval decision cycle  Hours to minutes 
Employee Onboarding  New hire ERP query resolution  Self-serve within 24 hours of system access 

 

The ROI calculation is yours to run before you commit to a build. Take your current ticket volume per function. Multiply by average handling time and burdened hourly cost. That is your baseline. Apply the chatbot’s deflection rate, and you have your minimum projected return — before decision speed improvements or error reduction are factored in.

Capturing that return only happens when the chatbot is built to the right standard. Most implementations fall short in predictable ways.

What Separates a High-Performance ERP AI Chatbot from a Costly Mistake

ERP AI chatbot implementations that fail do so for the same reasons, consistently. Understanding those failure points before you build is the difference between a deployment that scales and one that gets quietly abandoned six months after launch.

Custom-Trained vs. Off-the-Shelf

An off-the-shelf chatbot connected loosely to your ERP handles queries it was pre-trained on. A custom-trained system — built on your ERP’s actual data schema, your industry’s terminology, and your organization’s specific workflow logic — handles the queries your employees actually ask. 

Adoption data consistently shows this gap, and it shows up fast.

Deep ERP Integration vs. Middleware Workarounds

Middleware can connect a chatbot to your ERP faster. It cannot always give it the depth to trigger workflows, enforce business logic, or maintain real-time data accuracy. 

Knowing which architecture serves your use case requires ERP engineering knowledge. General software development experience is not a substitute for it.

Security and US Compliance Frameworks

Your ERP contains financial records, employee PII, vendor contracts, and operational data. The chatbot accessing it must operate with role-based access control, end-to-end encryption, session audit logging, and alignment with applicable US frameworks: SOC 2 Type II, HIPAA for healthcare enterprises, CCPA for California-regulated personal data, and NIST AI RMF for AI governance. 

These are architecture decisions, not compliance checkboxes reviewed at the end of a project.

Post-Deployment Optimization

A chatbot that does not improve over time is one that users abandon. Model retraining, conversation analytics, and feature iteration are not optional post-launch activities. 

They are the mechanism that makes the initial investment compound in value over time — and the item most often missing from vendor proposals.

These are baseline requirements, not competitive differentiators. The real-world proof of what gets built when these requirements are met is available in documented enterprise deployments.

ERP AI Chatbots in Practice: Use Cases

The business case is not theoretical. US enterprises and global organizations with comparable operational complexity have deployed these systems and published the results. These four implementations are worth studying before you scope your own build.

Heineken: Procurement Automation on SAP ERP

Heineken integrated an AI chatbot into its SAP ERP system to automate procurement workflows for brewing ingredient sourcing. Before deployment, manual procurement tasks produced a 30% error rate and regular delays in managing orders.

After deployment, procurement data error rates dropped from 30% to 5%. Order processing time improved by 300%. Vendor onboarding time compressed from months to weeks. 

Unilever: HR Self-Service at Global Scale

Unilever deployed an AI HR chatbot integrated into its ERP infrastructure to handle employee self-service queries across a global workforce. 

The deployment reduced internal HR ticket volume, accelerated recruitment cycles by 20%, and improved employee satisfaction scores within a measurable timeframe.

AmerisourceBergen (US): AI-Integrated ERP for Cost Intelligence

This US-based pharmaceutical distributor replaced manual spreadsheet-based production cost analysis with an AI-integrated ERP system. 

The new system automatically calculates production costs, analyzes historical transaction data, and incorporates external market signals in real time.

Walmart: SAP HANA at Transaction Scale

Walmart’s deployment of SAP HANA with AI capabilities enabled real-time processing of transaction records across more than 11,000 global store locations. What previously required an extended processing time now runs in seconds.

Each of these deployments was built by teams with deep ERP engineering knowledge and a structured development process. The next section details what that process looks like in practice.

What Custom ERP AI Chatbot Development Looks Like

Building a custom ERP AI chatbot is a structured engineering engagement, not a product deployment. The enterprises should understand each of the six phases before scoping a build. It changes the questions you ask vendors and what you include in a development brief.

ERP AI Chatbot Development Roadmap infographic showing 6 phases: Discovery, Architecture Design, ERP Integration, NLP Training, Deployment, and Optimization

Discovery

Audit existing ERP workflows, map high-friction use cases, and define success metrics alongside data access scope. This phase determines what you build first and why. Skipping it is how organizations end up building the wrong thing at full cost.

Architecture Design

Select the integration approach, define the security model, establish the RBAC framework, and confirm the ERP-specific connectivity method. For US enterprises in regulated industries, SOC 2, HIPAA, and CCPA requirements are resolved in this phase. Not retrofitted after launch.

ERP Integration

Build and test the connector layer between the AI system and your ERP modules. This is where ERP-specific engineering expertise determines whether the chatbot acts on your data or merely reads it. General software developers building this phase produce general results.

NLP Model Training

Train the language model on your ERP’s data vocabulary, workflow terminology, and real user query patterns. A model trained on generic data fails real enterprise queries. A model trained on your specific environment does not.

Staged Deployment

Roll out by department, not company-wide. Each department generates real usage data before the next expands. Staged deployment reduces risk, accelerates adoption, and gives you measurable proof of value at each step before broader rollout.

Continuous Optimization

Monitor conversation quality, retrain on failure cases, and expand use cases based on adoption data. This phase is what separates a chatbot that compounds in value from one that stagnates at its launch-day performance level.

The quality of each phase depends on who builds it. That decision comes down to choosing the right development team.

 

Also Read: How to Build An AI Chatbot? A Complete Guide

What to Look for When Hiring an ERP AI Chatbot Development Team in the US

For US enterprises evaluating development partners, the qualification is specific. You need a team with hands-on ERP engineering experience — not just AI development credentials — and one that treats US compliance requirements as architecture inputs from the first day of the engagement.

Proven ERP Engineering Depth

The team should have demonstrable, client-verifiable experience with your ERP platform. SAP, Oracle, Dynamics, NetSuite, or a custom system. Ask for specific integration examples, not general AI capability claims. 

The difference between a team that has built inside SAP and one that has not shows up within the first two weeks of a project.

NLP and LLM Specialization

Building a production-grade conversational layer requires expertise in intent modeling, dialogue flow design, and domain-specific model training. This is distinct from general software development. It is also distinct from general AI development. 

Both distinctions matter when your ERP holds business-critical workflows that cannot afford imprecision.

US Compliance Architecture Experience

SOC 2, HIPAA, CCPA, and NIST AI RMF are not afterthoughts for US enterprise deployments. A qualified development partner introduces these frameworks in the architecture phase. 

Any vendor who cannot speak specifically to compliance architecture at that stage has not built ERP chatbots for regulated US industries.

Post-Launch Optimization Commitment

Ask specifically how the partner handles model retraining, conversation quality monitoring, and feature iteration after deployment. A firm without a defined process for this has not built chatbots that survive their first year in production — and their proposal will not mention it.

Why Code Brew Labs is the Right Partner for Developing ERP AI Chatbots?

Code Brew Labs is a US-based custom software development company with a dedicated AI and ERP practice. We have built ERP AI chatbots on SAP, Oracle, Microsoft Dynamics, and custom enterprise platforms for clients across the US manufacturing, healthcare, financial services, and logistics sectors.

Our US development team operates under SOC 2-aligned engineering practices. We work directly inside your ERP environment from day one of the engagement, not around it through generic middleware.

We’ve built custom ERP AI chatbots for US enterprises.

 

The Future of ERP AI Chatbots: What US Enterprises Should Prepare For

The ERP AI chatbot market is not static. The capabilities available to US enterprises today are meaningfully more advanced than those from three years ago, and the next three years will move faster. These five developments will reshape how enterprises interact with their ERP systems.

Agentic AI: From Answering to Acting

The next step beyond conversational chatbots is agentic AI. These are systems that autonomously complete multi-step ERP workflows without waiting for a human prompt at each step. 

An agentic procurement system monitors supplier performance, flags anomalies, and initiates alternative sourcing. Nobody has to ask it to.

Gartner projects that 40% of enterprise applications will feature task-specific AI agents. That transition is not on the horizon. It is already underway in early adopter organizations.

Voice-First ERP Interfaces

Hands-free ERP access is becoming a priority for US manufacturers, warehouse operators, and field service organizations. 

Voice-enabled chatbots integrated with existing ERP systems reduce friction in environments where screen interaction is impractical or slows down operations.

Predictive Workflow Orchestration

Next-generation ERP chatbots will anticipate workflow needs based on behavioral patterns, rather than waiting for a query. Flagging a budget variance before the finance team notices. 

Surfacing a supplier risk before procurement sees the order fail. The chatbot shifts from reactive to proactive.

AI Governance and Explainability Requirements

US regulatory direction, including NIST AI RMF and evolving state-level AI legislation, is moving toward explainability requirements for enterprise AI systems. 

ERP chatbots that log decisions, surface reasoning, and maintain auditable interaction records will carry a compliance advantage. 

Building for explainability during the architecture phase costs far less than retrofitting it under regulatory pressure.

The ERP Chatbot as the Default Enterprise Interface

By 2030, industry analysts project that conversational AI will be the primary interface for most ERP interactions across US enterprise environments. 

The organizations building that capability today will not be catching up in 2028. They will be the standard others are trying to catch up to.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an ERP AI chatbot?

An ERP AI chatbot is a conversational AI system integrated directly into an enterprise resource planning platform. It allows users to query live data, trigger workflows, and complete processes using plain language, without navigating the ERP interface manually. 

How do ERP AI chatbots integrate with existing systems like SAP or Oracle?

Integration happens through one of three approaches: native connectors such as SAP Conversational AI or Oracle Digital Assistant, third-party middleware platforms, or custom API development. The right method depends on your ERP platform, the depth of workflow automation required, and your existing IT infrastructure. 

What are the main types of ERP AI chatbots?

The five primary types are rule-based (scripted, limited scope), NLP-powered (understands natural language intent), generative AI or LLM-driven (contextual responses and report generation), voice-enabled (hands-free for field and warehouse use), and agentic (autonomous multi-step workflow execution without human prompting). 

What US compliance frameworks apply to ERP AI chatbot deployments?

US enterprises should align chatbot architecture with SOC 2 Type II for security and availability controls, HIPAA for organizations processing health-related employee or patient data, CCPA for California-regulated personal data, and NIST AI RMF for AI governance. These frameworks belong in the architecture phase. 

How long does a custom ERP AI chatbot build take for a US enterprise?

A production-ready single-department deployment typically takes 10 to 18 weeks from discovery through staged rollout, assuming a defined use case and accessible ERP APIs. Multi-module, multi-department deployments on complex ERP stacks typically run 20 to 32 weeks. Timeline depends directly on ERP architecture complexity, compliance requirements, and the number of workflows included in the initial scope.

What does ERP AI chatbot development cost for a US enterprise?

Development cost varies by ERP platform, integration complexity, number of modules in scope, and compliance requirements. Single-department NLP chatbots on cloud ERPs with accessible APIs sit at the lower end of the investment range. Full multi-module, custom-integrated, compliance-aligned deployments represent a significantly higher investment. 

ERP AI chatbots are a structural shift in how US enterprises interact with the operational data they have already invested in organizing. 

For US enterprises in 2026, this is not a watch-and-wait decision. The organizations moving now are building an operational infrastructure advantage that takes years for competitors to close. 

Book Your ERP AI Chatbot Discovery Call 



×

Let’s Build Your Dream App!

Get In Touch
partnership
Join, Sell & Earn

Explore Our Partnership Program to Sell
Our Fully Customized Tech Solution To Your Clients.

Partner With Us!

Wait! Looking for Right Technology Partner For Your Business Growth?

It's Time To Convert Your Business Idea Into Success!

Get Free Consultation From Top Industry Experts:
I would like to keep it to myself